Grey cat playing with colorful interactive toy from FluffyPuppy Pet Supplies – ideal for engaging solo play

10 Tips for Choosing the Perfect Toys for Your Cat

The moment you step foot inside a pet store or browse for cat toys on the internet the number of available options can become overwhelming. Choosing between numerous colorful products and exciting shapes packaged with "best toy ever" promises proves difficult. The picture of a happy kitten alongside the thought of your cat's joy with a new toy usually convinces you to purchase the item. It happens occasionally despite our best efforts when these purchased toys become waste in the trash or stay unused.

Here’s a practical guide to help you make smart choices for toys that will captivate your furry friend. What to Look for When Buying Toys for Your Feline Friend

Essential Factors to Consider When Choosing Cat Toys

1. Safety is Non-Negotiable

Before giving your cat a new toy perform a quick assessment of its safety features. Check for tiny parts and pointy corners along with decorations that may detach easily from the toy. The removal of glued-on eyes and noses from plush toys will help prevent your cat from choking. Cats completely disregard these details and you should eliminate them to keep your cat safe. Safety is especially crucial for toys that your cat will play with unsupervised, such as the Interactive Bird Cat Toy.

Cat jumping and playing with an interactive bird toy attached to a window, promoting active and healthy fun.

During all play sessions inspect every toy before beginning play. If the toy has feathers or dangling parts, like the Cat Accordion Interactive Toy, ensure they’re securely attached. All interactive toys need to be put away safely after use to stop your cat from chewing on feathers or becoming entangled in strings.

Cat playing with an accordion-style interactive toy featuring rolling balls for hours of entertainment and stimulation.

2. Match the Toy Type to Your Cat’s Needs

Each cat requires different types of toys which help them stay active throughout the day. A wide selection of toys allows cats to fulfill their natural instincts during playtime.

  • Self-Play Toys: These toys allow cats to entertain themselves without human interaction. Balls, plush fish, small mice, or toys, which moves on its own, are excellent options for independent play.
  • Interactive Toys: These toys encourage mental stimulation and physical activity through engaging designs. A toy like the Cat Spiral Toy offers the perfect blend of challenge and reward, keeping your cat entertained and active.
  • Bonding Toys for Play with You: The toys for bonding sessions include sticks with feathers strings and bell toys to encourage you and your cat to play together. 

3. Movement that Mimics Prey

Cats are natural predators so they instinctively pursue items that move like prey. Choose toys which your cat can hit and bite and then pounce on. Toys that vibrate, wriggle, or respond to your cat’s touch, like the Smart Sensing Snake Toy, can keep them interested. You should mimic prey actions during play by placing the toy behind items or under a blanket to activate your cat's hunting instincts.

Two playful cats interacting with a smart sensing snake toy, offering fun and stimulation for your feline friends.

4. Size Makes a Difference

The size of the toy matters. Larger toys may frighten your cat especially when you have smaller cats or kittens in your household. Choose toys which your cat can easily hit and catch during play. The Cactus Cat Scratcher is a perfect example—large enough to engage, but not so big it overwhelms.

Cat playing on a cactus-shaped scratching post, providing a fun and durable surface for your pet to scratch and climb.

5. Consider Sound Sensitivity

The choice of toys depends heavily on the sounds they produce. Some cat toys produce squeaks or jingles yet not every cat finds them enjoyable. Some sounds can even be unsettling. Choose toys that produce subtle sounds such as soft rustling or quiet squeaks if your cat prefers quieter activities. Observe your cat's reactions to different sounds because this information will help you make better toy selections.

6. Texture Adds Variety

Toys exist in various textures including soft plush and firm chewable materials. Each texture provides a unique sensory experience for your cat. Observe your cat's reactions to different textures because this observation will help you make better purchasing decisions. Some cats tend to prefer biting soft toys whereas others tend to enjoy firmer toys.

How to Keep Your Cat Engaged with Toys

1. Start with a Mix of First Toys

When selecting toys for your kitten or young cat choose items with different textures and shapes and sounds. Introduce only a few toys to your cat at a time. Present toys by dressing them up as prey through placement in crinkly bags or under cushions. The exciting method of toy presentation enhances their interest and enthusiasm.

2. Rotate Toys to Keep Things Fresh

The same toy loses its appeal to cats after a period of time. The moment your cat shows signs of boredom you should consider replacing their toys. Periodic toy changes will help maintain your cat's interest level. Their attraction to softer toys as kittens might transition to other preferences as they grow older. Introducing new toys occasionally will help maintain the excitement of playtime.

Two playful cats enjoying a yellow spiral toy, showcasing interactive pet toys from FluffyPuppy for indoor fun.

3. DIY Toys are Fun, Too!

If you enjoy being creative, consider making some toys for your cat. Using household items you can create basic yet secure toys for your cat. You can create toys by rolling paper into balls and suspending feathers from strings and manufacturing crinkly paper objects. The internet hosts numerous simple DIY cat toy projects which need few resources and do not take much time to complete.

And while DIY toys can be great for variety, sometimes it’s worth investing in cozy play spaces like a Fluffy Cat Bed with Tunnel. Your cat will find both rest and play space in this bed which offers a cozy place to sleep and multiple hiding spots and pouncing opportunities. The perfect play space combines relaxation with entertainment for your feline companion.

Colorful fluffy cat tunnel bed with a kitten exploring, available at FluffyPuppy pet store.

4. Spend Time Playing Together

Your cat will always choose time spent with you over cat toys. Devote two separate periods of 15 minutes per day for hands-on interactions. Your bond with your cat strengthens while they receive mental stimulation and physical exercise through this time together. When you’re away, leave out safe toys like the Interactive Bird Toy or Sensing Snake Toy to entertain them. Your cat desires family membership and needs both attention and affection and time to play together with you.

Final Thoughts on Choosing Cat Toys

The process of selecting cat toys demands knowledge about individual preferences and requirements of your feline companion. Your cat will remain active and mentally sharp when you provide safe toys that also promote variety in their play. Your cat's playtime serves two essential purposes: it delivers vital joy and it maintains their mental health and physical health. Your bond with your cat will grow stronger while their activity level and health improve when you provide appropriate toys combined with interactive engagement.

Discover our full Pet Toys Collection at FluffyPuppy, where you’ll find everything from interactive toys for solo play to bonding toys for shared fun. Every play session with your cat should become a special moment that brings enrichment to their life.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.